This book had a lot of surprises in it. The first major one was Brad and Patrick being gay. I liked that it added this because I think that it reaches out to those in high school who are different and feel as though they will be outcasted because of it- a group of kids that don't always get that kind of attention in literature provided at schools. The biggest surprise in the book for me (and I'm assuming most) was when we found out that Charlie's aunt had molested him when he was little. When the psychiatrist asked him to focus on past memories, I kind of gathered that he had some sort of repressed memory, but I would have never expected that to of happened to him. When it came to that page I actually had to put the book down for a couple minutes because I was so shocked!
One thing that I liked and also hated, was the secrecy of the letters. I would have enjoyed finding out AT LEAST who "Charlie" was writing to and why this person stuck out to him so much. On the other hand, it was a creative way to write a book and the mystery of it left it to focus more on the overall moral of the book.
I enjoyed the ending. Even though it wasn't a happily-ever-after, it gave us hope for Charlie and it gave a good message about valuing family and friends who love you.
I think that I would consider teaching this in a classroom but I would probably rather recoomend it to an individual student. Some of the content may not be perceived appropriate for students (even though all of his letters are expressed in an innocent and relatable way) so I think it would be easier to be able to talk to an individual students parent(s) and discuss the content of the book.
I agree 100% with the secrecy of the letters and wanting to find out who he was writing to. It was fun in class to try and figure out who it was and I feel like some of the suggestions had good reasons behind them, but it is irritating that we will never know.
ReplyDeleteNot knowing who he was writing to was both exciting and frustrating. While I wish we would have found out, Chbosky clearly made a decision to leave it open. The more and more I think about it, I think he may be writing to us. If that was the case, it would mean that we were personally included in the novel and part of Charlie's story.
ReplyDeleteGreat point about the innocence of Charlie's behavior. I think if Charlie had been purposefully drinking, doing drugs, and being destructive (to hurt himself or others) people would be less willing to accept this novel. He is just simply growing up. He is not trying to hurt anyone or himself, this is one of his most likable traits.
Great thoughts, Carlee!
-Allison